Karen
Insurance in the USVI
Yes, insurance here is expensive because of hurricanes and possible flooding from such storms as find their way in to the Atlantic. The “replacement cost” on the appraisal is what the insurance companies look at when they decide what to charge you. The appraisal does not go by square footage alone. Other factors are what the house is constructed of and if it has hurricane shutters and clips. When purchasing a home, the appraisal will have this information. It will also have the three different ways the home was valued. With a concrete, shutterd three unit home the insurance will be over $10k/yr. Ouch! That breaks down to about $850/month. That is on top of the mortgage and taxes. The different insurance companies do have slightly different rates, so shop and compare.
The bank will require flood insurance for beachfront, waterfront, and low laying areas, or a flood certificate if your home is not in a flood zone. If you have rental apartments, I would suggest obtaining liability insurance. Liability insurance does not cost much extra and it is well worth it.